Monument to the victims of all wars in Ljubljana: Tradi-tion, its symbolic form and the perception of the community

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.22530/ayc.2023.23.634

Keywords:

Monument to the victims of all wars, Ljubljana, urban landmark, spatial perception, identity, symbolic form

Abstract

After an overview of the elementary theoretical considerations that describe how users build their image of an urban object, we allude to the tradition of building monuments during the socialist era, which is part of recent history and rich in examples of strong symbolism. In the following, we present the construction process of the monument to the fallen of all wars in which Slovenian citizens participated, which was erected in 2017 and is the main object of study in this article. After presenting the preliminary construction works, we discuss the relationship between the promising verbal descriptions of the future monument, the material reality that should have been materialized, and the users' perception of the site after it was built. A neutral form, as the monument has, for such an important content, according to several critics, does not symbolize what is expected of it. The user is the one who confirms the information in each description through his or her individual perception of the place. Most of the city's inhabitants do not identify with the image of the monument, nor with the message of separation between groups with opposing ideas, which unexpectedly arises from its form.

References

AUGE, M.(2006). Non-Places, Introduction to an Anthropology of Supermoderni-ty.Verso.

APIH, M. (2017, 22 de julio). Pisma bralcev [Cartas de lectores]. Sobotna pri-loga Dela, 31. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

AVILA, R. (2013). El arte según Aristóteles. https://filosofia.laguia2000.com/filosofia-griega/el-arte-segun-aristoteles

BUGARIC, B., DESMAN, K., IVANIC, M., KUHAR, S., MAVSAR, E., NARDONI KOVAC, S. y ZAVIRSEK HUDNIK, D. (2020). Arhitektura. Skulptura. Spomin. Architecture. Sculpture. Remembrance. Umetnost spomenikov Jugoslavije 19452020–1991 / The Art of Monuments of Yugoslavia 1945–1991. https://www.dessa.si/pdf/ZLOZENKA_spomeniki_CATALOGUE_monuments.pdf

COELHO, C. (2019). The Living Experience as a design content: from concept to appropriation. Direction Générale des Patrimoines - DAPA - MCC, UMR 1563 - Ambiances Architectures Urbanités (AAU). http://journals.openedition.org/ambiances/606.

CULLEN, G. (2006). The Concise Townscape. Elsevier.

FERENC, M. (2013, 19 de agosto). Spomenik vsem žrtvam bo nova Potemki-nova vas [El monumento a todas las víctimas será una nueva aldea Po-temkin] (html). Delo. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

GATTUPALLI, A. (2022 5 de septiembre). How Public Art Shapes Cities. Ar-chdaily. https://www.archdaily.com/

GRGIČ, J. (2017, 18 de septiembre). Žrtvam vseh vojn: Simbol sprave – na trgu, ki ga ni [A las víctimas de todas las guerras: Un símbolo de reconci-liación - en una plaza que no existe]. Delo. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

HILLIER, B. & HANSON, J. (1989). The Social Logic of Space. Cambridge Univ. Press.

JACOBEIT, S. (2016). Die verzerrte Sprache des Gedenkens [El lenguaje distorsio-nado de la conmemoracion]. Institut für Europäische Ethnologie http://www.euroethno.huberlin.de

JOGAN, M. (2016). Spomenik sprave v glavnem mestu [El monumento a la reconciliacion en la capital]. https://www.svobodnabeseda.si/spomenik-sprave-v-glavnem-mestu-slovenije/slovenije

KOLSEK, P. (2017, 5 de agosto). Metafizika v avgustu [Metafisica en agosto]. Sobotna priloga Dela, 32. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

KOSIR, F. (2017, 22 de julio). Pisma bralcev [Cartas de lectores]. Sobotna pri-loga Dela, 31. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

LEFEVBRE, H. (1974). La production de l'espace [La produccion del espacio]. An-thropos.

LIDIN, K. (2021). Happiness and Urban Environment. Academia Letters, Ar-ticle 1853. https://doi.org/10.20935/AL1853.

LYNCH, K. (1990). The image of the city (1ª ed., 1964 (199020). The MIT Press.

NIEBYL, D. (2016). An exploration of Yugoslavia's historic and enigmatic en-deavor into abstract anti-fascist WWII monument building between 1960 & 1990. https://www.spomenikdatabase.org/

PALLASMAA, J. (2011). The Embodied image. Imagination and Imaginery in Ar-chitecture. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

ROCHA, T. (2017). Spatial Perception and Architecture. https://www.tomasrochavision.com/percepcion-visual/2017

SKAZA, M. (2019) Architecture as a Consequence of Perception En: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, vol. 471, n. 2, pp. 1-8. IOP Publishing Ltd.

STEVANOVIC, N (2018). Patrimonio Arquitectónico de carácter Yugoslavo-socialista: Ideología, Memoria e Identidad. Universitat Politècnica de Cata-lunya.

ZAJC, M. (2020). Spomenik Pr’ Skelet in Zvezdi: k politiki spomina v Slove-niji vdrugem desetletju tretjega tisočletja [Monumento entre Esqueleto y Zvezda: la política de la memoria en Eslovenia en la segunda década del tercer milenio]. Prispevki za novejšo zgodovino LX – 1/2020, 151-172.

ZEROVC, B. (2017). Spomenik, ki bo zapičen v naše osrčje za vselej - Koliko sploh razmišljamo o novodobni produkciji javnih skulptur in spomeni-kov? [Un monumento que quedará grabado en nuestros corazones para siempre. ¿Cuánto pensamos en la producción moderna de esculturas y monumentos públicos?]. Delo. https://www-delo-si/arhiv

ZEROVC, B. (2019). Javni spomeniki in spomeniki, posvečeni prvi svetovni vojni, na območju Jugoslavije od poznega 19. stoletja do leta 1941 [Mo-numentos públicos y monumentos dedicados a la Primera Guerra Mun-dial en el territorio de Yugoslavia desde finales del siglo XIX hasta 1941]. Ars & Humanitas, 13(2), 203–230. https://doi.org/10.4312/ars.13.2.203-230

Published

2023-05-14

How to Cite

Tomsic-Amon, B. (2023). Monument to the victims of all wars in Ljubljana: Tradi-tion, its symbolic form and the perception of the community. ARTE Y CIUDAD. Research Journal, (23), 49–70. https://doi.org/10.22530/ayc.2023.23.634

Issue

Section

Artículos